Back to Blog

How to stop users signing up for a free trial again with a new email

Someone can start a free trial again with a new email in about a minute. Why unique emails miss it, and each basic fix by effort and where it breaks.

Hi, this is a bit awkward. We've paid you $49 a month for two years. Last week a contractor of ours mentioned they've been using your product since June and have never paid. When a trial runs out, they sign up again with a new email. They say it takes about a minute, and that a few people in their group chat do the same. I'm not trying to get anyone in trouble. I'd just like to know why I'm paying for something other people get for free. Should I cancel and do that too?

Dana

Say that's waiting in your support inbox at 9:26 on a Tuesday. It's a scenario, but read it as yours. Dana has paid you $1,176 over those two years (24 × $49), and this is the first complaint you've ever had from them.

By 10:30 you've found the contractor's accounts. There are 11, each opened within a day of the last trial ending, each with a verified email, each used hard for 14 days. A fully used trial costs you $14 in model and compute charges, so 11 × $14 = $154 went on one person who was never going to pay. That's over three months of what Dana pays you (3 × $49 = $147).

Nothing warned you, because someone starting a free trial again with a new email looks exactly like a new customer. So you spend the afternoon in the logs, and by 5 p.m. you have a rough count: 70 people running trials back to back. A 14-day trial fits into a month about twice, so:

70 people x 2 trials a month = 140 trials
140 trials x $14             = $1,960 a month
$1,960 x 12 months           = $23,520 a year

That $1,960 is the whole monthly payment of 40 customers like Dana (40 × $49). If your company spends $16,000 a month, $23,520 is about six weeks of runway, handed to 70 people for the same product everyone else pays for.

Then you open the number you've been reporting. Last month you had 420 trial starts and 21 new customers, so 5% (21 ÷ 420). It's in your last investor update. It's why you rewrote onboarding in the spring and spent a month wondering if $49 was too high. Now take out the 140 repeat trials: 21 ÷ 280 = 7.5%. One trial start in three (140 of 420) came from someone who'd already had one, and the growth you were pointing at was partly the same 70 people coming round again. You made those calls reasonably, on the number you had. The number was wrong.

It's 5:40 and Dana still hasn't had a reply. If they cancel, that's $588 a year gone (12 × $49), and the reason will travel. The ways out that come to mind all land on the people you built the trial for: cut it short, put a card in front of it, or pull it. That trial brought you all 21 of last month's new customers.

Why a new email gets a new trial

You meant one trial per person. What your signup form enforces is one trial per email address, because the address is the only thing it has to go on, and a second address costs nothing.

Signs up, second emailIs this email taken?No matching rowSends confirmation codeEnters the codeCreate account and trialWelcome to your trialEvery step passedSame personSignup formYour databaseSame personSignup formYour database
Signs up,secondemailIs thisemailtaken?NomatchingrowSendsconfirmationcodeEnters thecodeCreateaccountand trialWelcometo your trialEvery step passedSamepersonSignupformYourdatabaseSamepersonSignupformYourdatabase

Every step there worked. That address really was new, and the code really did reach its owner. So the obvious fix, making email addresses unique, doesn't help. You already have it, and it did its job.

Some people restart because they'd happily pay $15 and can't justify $49, which makes it a pricing problem as much as an abuse problem. Before you build anything, decide what you meant, one trial per person ever or one every 12 months, and put it in a one account per person policy.

Fixes for free trial restarts, cheapest first

Each of these catches something real. What differs is how much, and what it costs to keep working.

An afternoon: unique emails and verification

Keep both. A unique rule stops the same address twice, and a confirmation code stops typos and addresses nobody owns. Almost nobody gets wrongly blocked, apart from people whose code lands in spam, and both are cheap to run. Any second real inbox still passes, because verified only means someone can open that inbox.

Gmail ignores dots, so jane.doe@gmail.com and janedoe@gmail.com reach one inbox, and mail to jane+news@gmail.com lands there too. Treating those as one address catches the laziest repeats and misses a second real mailbox completely.

A day or two: domain lists, CAPTCHA, IP limits and VPN blocks

A disposable-domain block catches known throwaway services. It misses new domains and every ordinary free mailbox, it turns away people who use privacy forwarding, and someone has to keep that list current forever.

CAPTCHA stops simple scripts, and the contractor isn't a script. They're a person filling in a form, which is what a CAPTCHA is designed to let through, while people on screen readers and privacy tools can get stuck on it. It has other limits too.

One trial per IP address catches a second signup on the same connection and nothing past it. It can also hurt you, because an office, campus or household can share one address, so the second person evaluating you at a company gets refused. VPN blocks have the same shape: they catch known ranges, miss everything off your list and refuse staff on company VPNs along the way. Rate limits catch bursts and can slow real users in a busy hour, and one signup every 14 days is some of the slowest traffic you'll ever see.

A sprint and a hit to signups: cards, phones, caps and shorter trials

A card requirement is the strongest basic on this page, since a second card is harder to come by than a second email. Anyone who has one still gets through, and students and people who want to try first leave at the form. Say it costs you 3 of those 21 customers a month. That's $147 of new monthly revenue lost each month, so after a year you're $1,764 a month behind (36 × $49). Run your own version.

A phone requirement slows casual second accounts too. It lets through anyone with another number, shuts out people without a reliable mobile and bills you for every text.

Shorter trials look like the easy win. Cut 14 days to 7 and a fully used trial costs $7. But those 70 people now restart about four times a month, and 70 × 4 × $7 = $1,960, the same bill as before. Every honest user just got half the time.

Usage caps do help. A hard spending cap puts a ceiling on each account, though every new account gets a fresh one and honest people hit it too.

Forever: manual review

A person can see what a rule can't. At two minutes per signup, 420 trial starts is 840 minutes, or 14 hours every month, and the trial is usually well under way before anyone looks. Whoever seems odd to a tired reviewer gets refused.

Illustrative effort vs protectionStrong but costlyCheap and strongCheap and weakCostly and weakLow effortHigh effortWeak protectionStrong protectionUnique emailsEmail verificationAlias rulesDisposable blocksCard requiredPhone requiredManual review
Illustrative effort vs protectionStrong butcostlyCheap andstrongCheap andweakCostly andweakLow effortHigh effortWeak protectionStrongprotectionUnique emailsEmail verificationAlias rulesDisposable blocksCard requiredPhone requiredManual review

The top left is empty. Among the basics, nothing is both cheap and strong against someone with a second email. Stack them all and an honest person confirms an email, solves a puzzle, gives a phone number and enters a card, while the contractor needs one more of each.

What to do about repeat trials this week

  1. Reply to Dana today.
  2. Hold costly work until the email is confirmed, so unverified signups stop spending your money.
  3. Record each trial on your server with its start date, so one account can't restart it.
  4. Make a restart cost something. Keep projects, history and settings in the account, so a new trial starts empty. It blocks nobody.
  5. Offer a way to pay less, such as a smaller plan or a paid extension.
  6. Report conversion both ways, with and without known repeats.

A reply you can send

Thanks for telling us, and for two years of paying for this. Starting a new trial to avoid paying isn't something we allow, and we're working on it now.

All of that shrinks the problem. None of it answers what Dana was really asking: has this person already had a trial? Your records can answer that for an account. They can't answer it for someone who arrives under a new address.

One answer before the trial starts

Whether a new claim looks like a repeat is what AbuseZero was built to answer. Where a new address passed your unique rule, AbuseZero recognizes repeat devices across new accounts, even when email addresses keep changing. Your card requirement only asks for a valid card, so the same one can come back on a new account. AbuseZero detects repeated payment fingerprints across users, even when new accounts and emails hide the connection. That list of domains you'd be updating forever? AbuseZero checks mailbox aliases, disposable domains and mail routing. Your IP limit saw one address, and AbuseZero sees beyond it with VPN, hosting, network reputation, Tor and proxy intelligence. The headline number is 140,000+ signals: multi-layer AI risk analysis examines them, detects linked claims and flags abuse that single checks miss. Those signals are read together, never one at a time. There's also a proprietary algorithm, with AI that checks the claim again. Creating a fresh account isn't enough to erase previous activity.

You make one API call before the trial starts and get a clear allow or deny, under rules you control. A trial can be once per user, or once per rolling number of days. Observe mode shows you what would be denied before anyone is blocked. You don't have to build your own abuse prevention system, and the quickstart protects your first benefit.

Frequently asked questions

Is every second trial abuse?

No. Someone may come back a year later, or join a new company. Here's how to tell a returning customer from a duplicate account, and what to say when someone asks for a second trial.

Should I just remove the free trial?

In the scenario above, pulling it saves $1,960 a month and loses 21 new customers a month. By month two you're missing 42 customers, or $2,058 a month (42 × $49), which is already more than you saved.

How do I find the repeat trials I already have?

Start with this audit of your own database.

Keep your trial for people who might buy

Keep reading

Copying your prompt…

Copied the to your clipboard. Give it to your coding agent & it will handle the rest.