Back to Blog

How to protect free documents in an e-signature tool

A free e-signature plan can lose your best customers to one spare email address. Why it happens, which basic fixes break and what to do about it.

Businesses keep opening extra accounts to get more free documents out of your e-signature tool, and each one that does is a paying customer you were counting on and won't get.

This is a scenario, with numbers you can swap for your own. It's a Thursday in March, 10:26 a.m., and this lands in your support inbox from a property management company you've been waiting on for over a year:

Support ticket

Hi, we need the signed lease for Apartment 4B and we can't find it. We've got a few accounts with you and it could be in any of them. Can you search across them? They're leasing@, office@ and info@, plus two personal ones I'll have to dig out.

You know this company. Fourteen months ago it sent its third lease of the month, hit your 0 of 3 documents left screen and answered your upgrade email: "Makes sense, we'll move over when the spring rush starts." You marked it as a likely upgrade. When spring passed, you figured they'd gone quiet. They were still sending, from five logins.

That's what e-signature free documents abuse looks like from the inside. Nothing spiked and no alert fired, because all it took was an office manager and a spare email address.

Your free plan gives 3 documents a month. Your paid plan is $29 a month for up to 25. This company sends 11 leases a month:

  • 11 documents ÷ 3 free per account = 3.67, so 4 accounts cover a normal month and the fifth covers a busy one
  • 11 leases × 14 months = 154 leases sent through your product
  • 14 months × $29 = $406 you expected and never got
  • 154 documents × $0.30 = $46.20 you paid to send, remind and store them ($0.30 is an assumption, so use your own figure)

Now look at what they got. One 12-month lease at $1,800 rent is $1,800 × 12 = $21,600 of signed rent. Eleven of those is $237,600, every month, on a plan you give away. The amount they saved each month was $29.

One company is $406. So you open your upgrade report. Say about 120 accounts hit 0 of 3 for the first time each month. A year ago, 30 of them upgraded. Now it's 15, and you've spent two quarters blaming that screen. You rewrote it twice and tested a new price in the upgrade email. Say the missing 15 did what this company did:

  • 15 missing upgrades × $29 = $435 of new monthly revenue that doesn't arrive, every month
  • After 12 months: 15 × 12 × $29 = $5,220 a month you were counting on
  • Cash gone in that year: $435 × (1 + 2 + ... + 12) = $435 × 78 = $33,930, leaving churn aside
Monthly revenue missing, illustrative0100020003000400050006000123456789101112US dollars a monthMonth
Monthly revenue missing, illustrative02000400060001357911US dollars a monthMonth

At $0.30 a document, no spending alert will ever fire, because the damage is money that didn't arrive. If you spend $22,000 a month, $33,930 is about 1.5 months of runway ($33,930 ÷ $22,000 = 1.54). It's also the contractor you didn't hire, which is why bulk send still isn't built. The property managers who do pay you have been asking for it since last summer, and they're paying full price for a stalled roadmap.

You can't just shut the accounts, either. Those five logins hold signed leases, and tenants have links to them. Suspend one and a tenant who did nothing wrong can't get to their own lease. And the ticket is still open. Search across all five and you've told this company it's fine. Refuse and you lose the one account that just admitted it needs you.

So you think about cutting the free plan to 1 document a month, and then you do that sum too. 11 ÷ 1 = 11 accounts instead of 4. Honest new senders get a third of what they had. And say most of your customers found you through that plan, because every signing request that goes out puts your name in front of someone who may need one too.

Why e-signature free plans are so easy to stack

Most free plan abuse needs scale. An e-signature plan needs one more account. If you sign 6 contracts a month, 2 accounts cover you for good, and nobody in that office thinks of it as abuse.

A signed document also leaves your product the moment it's done. The PDF and its audit trail go into a shared drive, and the account that produced them has no further job. Signers don't need an account at all, so no tenant ever notices the sender changed. A new login is one uploaded PDF and a couple of signature fields away from being useful.

The value runs the wrong way as well. A lease signed on your free plan is the same finished lease as one signed on your paid plan. A free document fully replaces a paid one, so a monthly cap only sets how many logins a business needs.

That makes low volume and high value the corner to worry about:

Illustrative free document stacking riskPays without askingExtra account covers itFree plan is enoughOutgrows free fastFew documentsMany documentsLow value eachHigh value eachProperty managerSolo consultantSales teamClub formsGym waivers
Illustrative free document stacking riskPays withoutaskingExtra accountcovers itFree plan isenoughOutgrows freefastFew documentsMany documentsLow value eachHigh value eachProperty managerSolo consultantSales teamClub formsGym waivers

A gym sending 400 waivers a month would need 134 free accounts (400 ÷ 3 = 133.3), so it pays.

Not every second account is abuse. A company with two branches or a consultant with a side business may be exactly what you meant to allow. Decide that first, and write the policy down.

The basic fixes for free document limits, and how they break

Most teams start with the email address. A unique-email rule compares strings. Gmail ignores dots and plus-tagged mail reaches the same inbox, so one mailbox can be written several ways. This company didn't need any of that. The addresses leasing@, office@ and info@ are real mailboxes, and all three verify.

Basic fixWhat it catchesWhat it missesWho it wrongly blocksWhat it costs to keep working
Email verificationTypos and dead addressesEvery real mailbox a business ownsSenders whose code lands in spamDeliverability work
Disposable-domain blocksKnown throwaway servicesWork and personal mailboxesPeople using privacy forwardingA list someone updates forever
Gmail dots and plus addressingOne Gmail inbox written several waysA second real mailboxDifferent people it treats as oneUpkeep as mail services change
CAPTCHASimple scriptsAn office manager signing up by handPeople using screen readersFees and lost signups
Phone requirementCasual second accountsAnyone with another numberSenders on a desk phoneA charge for every text
Card requirementCasual second accountsA company with more than one cardFirms where only the owner holds the cardFewer signups
One per IP addressRepeat signups on one connectionAny other networkShared office buildings and coworking spacesExceptions and tickets
Monthly document capsOne account going past 3Each new account's fresh 3A sender in the middle of a dealDeciding what a fourth send does
Manual reviewWhat a person can spotAnything that looks like a new customerWhoever looks odd to the reviewerHours every month

Say you add a phone requirement this week. It slows that company down for about as long as it takes to find another number, and the landlord who wanted to send one lease from a desk phone leaves without telling you why. A card requirement does the same to a firm where only the owner holds the card.

Manual review has a price. 120 accounts × 4 minutes = 480 minutes, or 8 hours a month. And what would the reviewer look at? A new account that uploads a lease looks just like a new customer, because for all you can tell it is one. You want to know if this is the same business coming back, and nothing in that table can tell you.

What to do about free documents this week

Put what a business needs on the paid plan. Shared search across a team, reusable templates and your own branding are good candidates. That ticket is a company telling you what it would pay for. Leave signing and the audit trail alone on the free plan.

Turn the ticket into an offer. Merge the accounts into one paid account and keep every signed document reachable.

Count what happens at the cap. Each month, record how many accounts that hit 0 of 3 upgraded, left or kept sending. Measure the rate before you touch that screen again.

A reply you can send

We've found the lease for 4B, sorry for the hunt. If you'd like everything in one place, we can bring all five accounts together on one $29 plan, so your whole team can search every signed document.

Those steps make upgrading more attractive. They don't decide anything when a new account asks for its 3 free documents, and that moment still needs an answer: should this claim go through?

Before the next 3 free documents go out

AbuseZero was built for that moment, and a free plan like yours is what it's for. You make one API call before the free documents are granted and get a clear allow or deny, under rules you control. Creating a fresh account isn't enough to erase previous activity, and that's what a fifth login is counting on. Every address in that ticket could clear every row of the table. AbuseZero's multi-layer AI risk analysis examines 140,000+ signals, detects linked claims and flags abuse that single checks miss. It recognizes repeat devices across new accounts, even when email addresses keep changing, and it detects repeated payment fingerprints across users, even when new accounts and emails hide the connection. Its proprietary algorithm, with AI that checks the claim again, comes with the same API call.

Eligibility can be once, or once per calendar month, so your 3 documents stay the allowance you meant. Observe mode shows what would be denied before anyone is blocked, so you can review a month of 0 of 3 accounts first. You don't have to build your own abuse prevention system to keep a free plan free, and the quickstart protects your first benefit.

Frequently asked questions

What is e-signature free documents abuse?

It's a business opening extra accounts to get more free documents than you meant to give it.

Should an e-signature tool remove its free plan?

Try everything else first. Your free plan puts your name in front of signers. Should you remove your free tier? works through the trade-off.

Can I delete duplicate accounts that hold signed documents?

Be careful. Signers may rely on those documents, so merge instead of deleting where you can.

How do I decide which new accounts get free documents?

Write your rule, then evaluate each claim before you grant it. AbuseZero's evaluation returns allow or deny, and you can tell a denied sender what to do next.

Keep your free documents for new senders

Keep reading

Copying your prompt…

Copied the to your clipboard. Give it to your coding agent & it will handle the rest.